There are thousands of self-help books out there about relationships – getting into them, understanding them, saving them, living happily ever after because of them. Funny thing is, only women are reading the books.
Why?
Because this is what men think about relationships…
Want proof? Ask the average women to remember the month and year of some random event in her past. You’ll almost certainly get something like this:
“Let’s see, that was back when I just started going out with Tom – the summer of ’94. Then in December we broke up and I moved out to Indianapolis and met…”
A guy, on the other hand, uses a slightly different set of landmarks:
“Yeah, that was the year I had that ’65 Camaro. Hell of a car! Couldn’t corner worth a damn but give her a straightaway…”
So the first problem is that only half the population is even trying to figure out how to make relationships work (and let’s face it – they’re generally not the half with the problem). And to make matters worse, most of those self-help books that women are so earnestly poring over night after night miss the mark entirely.
For example (let’s start with an oldie):
The Rules
Time Tested Secrets for Capturing the Heart of Mr. Right.
By Ellen Fein and Sherrie Schneider
I HATE this book.
You only have to take one look at the table of contents to find out what a Rules Girl is like.
Rule 4: Don’t Meet Him Halfway.
Rule 5: Rarely Return His Calls.
Rule 12: Stop Dating Him if He Doesn’t Buy You a Romantic Gift.
Ms. Manners would be appalled. My mother would be appalled. But then the authors have taken care both of them with Rule 27:
Rule 27: Do The Rules, Even when Your Friends and Parents Think It’s Nuts.
And finally, if you do follow their formula with absolute precision, if you “don’t talk to your therapist, parents, or friends about the Rules.” If you “don’t read any books that go counter to the Rules” then you will win the ecstatic, Cinderella finale….
Rule 33: Do The Rules and You’ll Live Happily Ever After!
Does this sound like a cult to anyone but me?
But what I detest most about this book is its premise: that if you sit demurely with your ankles crossed, looking down at the table; if you don’t talk too much (or at all); if you act mysterious and pretend to be interested in his stamp collection and his obsession with watching water polo on TV, then you will get the ultimate prize – a ring on your finger and the right to laugh at all those other non-Rules girls who are facing the ugly maw of spinsterhood.
Here are a few more helpful hints from Madam Fein and Madam Schneider.
- “Suppress your intelligence and vivacious personality. Men will love it!”
(Sure. All men like to go out with a door knob.)
- “Be quiet and reserved. He’ll wonder what you’re thinking and if he’s making a good impression on you.”
(He’ll wonder IF you’re thinking, if you ever think, or if you just have the IQ of a carrot.)
- “Look down, look around, don’t look at him.”
(He’ll wonder if you’re wanted by the law, have a foot fetish, or perhaps have lost a contact lens.)
- “Men feel good when they have to work hard to see you. Don’t take that away from them.”
(Ah, the Last Man Standing approach. This may work in Hollywood pitch sessions, on American Idol, and in war zones, but probably not on a first date.)
- “Don’t return his calls. Don’t worry about seeming rude.”
(Where were they brought up? My mother needs to have a chat with their mothers.)
- “End phone calls first. ‘I have a million things to do.’”
(… “all of them more important than you are.” Exactly the kind of words to make a man swoon.)
- “If you are a genuinely nice person, you will probably feel cruel when you do the Rules. You will think you are making men suffer, when in reality you are doing them a favor.”
(I’m genuinely baffled by this one. You’re nice… but feel cruel. You think you’re hurting someone… but you’re doing them a favor. Yup, that’s true Rules Reasoning.)
- [Read a newspaper to] “fill your head with something other than how your first name sounds with his last name. If you’re anything like us, you’ve named your children before he says hello.”
(Nothing, nothing like you. Really.)
- “When your hair falls in front of your face, tilt your head back and comb back your hair with your hand from the top of your head with a slow, sweeping gesture… hike up your skirt to entice the opposite sex.”
(I feel like bait in a raccoon trap.)
10. “Even Playboy types will mend their ways as long as you follow the Rules.”
(Ahem. Rule 18: Don’t Expect a Man to Change or Try to Change Him.)
11. “Women can sip Perrier on dates with men who drink and smoke, and are now married to them.”
(Lovely – a life sentence with an alcoholic ashtray.)
12. “If you have a bad nose, get a nose job. Grow your hair long. Men prefer long hair.”
(Excuse me?… MY body. Not his. Or yours, ladies.)
13. And, happily, “it is not necessary to have a high IQ to do the Rules.”
(Neither, apparently, is it necessary to have a high IQ to write the Rules.)
Now, neither Ms. Fein nor Ms. Schneider pretends to have a PhD, but they do aspire to their very own, unique brand of logic to prove that their system works. It runs something like this:
Pam, “our dentist friend”, met Robert in dental school. “She spoke to him first,” thereby breaking Rule #2. They became lovers. They even lived together. But, alas, three years later he broke up with her over something trivial. Why? Because she broke Rule #2.
Yup, I’m totally convinced.
Take this short quiz to find out if you qualify to be a Rules Girl.
Before you go on a first date with a guy, you:
A. Spend the day at the mall, the gym, or with your friends.
B. Tell a girlfriend where and when you’re going, pick a safe venue, then get dressed and head out the door, ready to have a great time.
C. Spend hours doodling combinations of your first name with his last name and choosing the kind of flowers you want for your wedding.
As you walk through the front entrance to your apartment complex, and the doorman smiles and greets you. You:
A. Smile and wish him a nice evening.
B. At least give him a quick nod as you run for the elevator.
C. Do not look at him, smile at him, or greet him. You are a RULES girl!
It’s your birthday, and your boyfriend surprises you with a week-long vacation to an all-inclusive resort in Cancun. You:
A. Grab your suitcase and start packing! Don’t forget the sunscreen.
B. Give him a huge kiss and then grab your suitcase and start packing. Don’t forget the sunscreen.
C. If you don’t get jewelry from him on your birthday, you might as well end it because he’s not in love with you.
Of course, Ellen Fein (one of the authors) filed for divorce in 2000, shortly before the first Rules book came out. But then, The Rules are about getting married, not staying married. (Even more interestingly, she didn’t bother to tell her publishers, so the jacket of the first printing reads “Fein and Schneider, two longtime married women themselves…”). Obviously honestly is also not a Rules trait.
The Rules is apparently also about making its authors rich. They’re now selling several new books (one on how to stay married!), a newsletter, a Rules School, support groups, phone consultations ($250 each or $75 to email a single question), speaking engagements (call for price), an inspirational rap song (“Just Do The Rules”), CDs, DVDs, and a 12-week email course ($1,000). If that’s not enough, there’s a dating journal to help you keep track of your dating behavior – good and bad, Note cards (2 for $10), and even Rules lipstick (for “Rules Lips”: $15). And, if it’s still not working for you, you can always sign up to become a Rules Facilitator in Japan.
But hey, let’s give these poor ladies a break. It’s not like they had a choice.
“Even we didn’t want The Rules to be true.”
Recent Comments